Lapse

I found it today. It was tucked inside the back cover of a first-edition copy of *A Moveable Feast* I haven’t opened since I moved back to Malibu. The paper is that heavy, cream-colored stock from the Crillon, the kind that feels like it’s trying too hard to be important. My handwriting hasn't changed much—still that frantic, loopy scrawl that looks like a cardiogram of someone having a heart attack—but the woman who wrote it feels like a character I played once and can't quite remember how to inhabit anymore. I’m forty-two now. I’m sitting on my deck, watching the Pacific eat the shoreline, and I’m reading the words I wrote when I was twenty-nine and drowning in a city that was supposed to be romantic but just felt like a very expensive stage set. I never sent it. I suppose I knew even then that sending it would be like lighting a match in a room full of gas. You were Marc’s brother. You were the one who wasn't supposed to happen. But here it is. The letter. The morning after the afternoon that ruined everything and fixed nothing. *** October 14, 2014 Elias, I’m writing this because if I don’t, the words are going to turn into something toxic inside my chest. It’s 6:00 AM. The rain in Paris doesn’t fall; it just hangs there like a scrim, diffusing the light until the Place de la Concorde looks like a high-budget period piece with no plot. I’m sitting at the small mahogany desk in the corner of the suite, listening to the radiator hiss like it’s judging me. Yesterday was a mistake. Let’s start there. It was a beautiful, catastrophic, inevitable mistake. I remember seeing you at the Café de Flore. I was three minutes early, which is a sin in this city, and I sat there watching the street, feeling the dampness of my trench coat seep into my shoulders. Then you walked around the corner, and the whole frame shifted. You weren’t wearing a raincoat. You never did. You were just in that charcoal sweater and the boots you’ve had since university, looking like you’d just stepped out of a master shot by Deakins—everything high-contrast and slightly too sharp for the world around you. When you sat down, you didn’t apologize for being late. You just looked at me, and for a second, I forgot that I was married to your brother. I forgot the three years of strained Thanksgiving dinners where we barely made eye contact over the turkey. I forgot that I was a 'good woman' and you were the 'family problem.' “You look like you’re waiting for a bus that isn’t coming, Chloe,” you said. “I’m waiting for my brother-in-law,” I replied, trying to sound like a person who had her life under control. “He’s supposed to be giving me the keys to Marc’s apartment in the Marais.” “The keys are in my pocket,” you said, leaning back. The waiter came by, and you ordered a double espresso and a cognac at two in the afternoon. “But I’m not sure I want to give them to you yet. You look like you need a drink more than you need a set of keys.” “It’s raining, Elias.” “It’s always raining. That’s the point of this city. It forces you to go inside.” We sat there for an hour, and the banter was exactly what it always was—a series of sharp-edged comments designed to keep the subtext from becoming the text. We talked about Marc’s promotion, about the house in Connecticut I was supposed to be decorating, about the script you were struggling to finish. But the whole time, I was watching the way your thumb traced the rim of your glass. I was noticing the tiny scar on your knuckle that I’d never seen before. I was noticing that you looked at me the way a man looks at something he’s already decided to break. “Let’s walk,” you said finally. We didn’t go to the Marais. We walked toward the river. The rain picked up, turning the Seine into a churning ribbon of slate. My umbrella was useless; the wind kept catching it, pulling it like a kite, until you reached out and took the handle from me. Your hand brushed mine, and the contact was like a jump-cut—sudden, jarring, and impossible to ignore. “You’re shivering,” you said. “I’m fine.” “You’re a terrible liar. You always have been. That’s why Marc likes you. He thinks you’re transparent.” “And you? What do you think?” “I think you’re a deep-focus shot with a lot of noise in the background,” you said, stepping closer. We were under the awning of a closed bookstore. The air smelled of wet paper and old stone. “I think you’re terrified that if you stop moving, you’ll realize you’re bored out of your mind.” “I’m not bored.” “You’re married to my brother. He schedules sex for Tuesday nights and thinks the height of spontaneity is ordering Italian instead of Thai. You’re bored, Chloe. You’re so bored you’re vibrating.” I should have slapped you. I should have taken the keys and walked away. But instead, I just stood there, watching the rain drip off the edge of the awning. I felt like I was in a scene that had been rewritten too many times, and we were finally getting to the version where the characters stopped lying. “The Crillon is two blocks away,” you whispered. “I have a suite there. My producer is paying for it. It has a bathtub the size of a small car and a view that makes you feel like you own the world.” “I have Marc’s apartment,” I said, but my voice was a stage whisper, thin and unconvincing. “The apartment is empty, Chloe. It’s full of Marc’s furniture and Marc’s choices. Come to the Crillon. Just for an hour. To dry off.” That was the line. The lie we both agreed to tell. When we got to the suite, the silence was heavy. It was the kind of silence you get on a set right before the director calls 'Action.' Everything felt heightened. The texture of the velvet curtains, the weight of the crystal decanter on the sideboard, the sound of my own breath. I stood in the center of the room, my hair plastered to my forehead, water dripping from the hem of my coat onto the Persian rug. You didn't turn on the lights. The room was bathed in that soft, blue-grey dusk, the city lights beginning to prick through the gloom outside the floor-to-ceiling windows. You walked behind me. I felt the heat of your body before you even touched me. It was a physical presence, a pressure in the air. You reached around and unknotted the belt of my trench coat. You did it slowly, with the deliberate care of a wardrobe stylist. “You’re soaking wet,” you murmured, your breath hot against the back of my neck. “Elias, we can’t.” “We already are.” You peeled the coat off my shoulders, letting it heavy-thud to the floor. Then your hands were on my waist, pulling me back against you. I could feel the hard line of your thighs through my silk dress. My heart was a frantic bird trapped in a cage of ribs. I turned around in your arms, intending to say something about loyalty, about Marc, about the fact that this was a betrayal that could never be un-done. But you didn't give me the chance. You grabbed the back of my head, your fingers tangling in my wet hair, and you kissed me. It wasn't a gentle kiss. It wasn't a 'first-time' kiss. It was a collision. It was three years of repressed glances and polite dinner conversations exploding all at once. It tasted like cognac and rain and desperation. I opened my mouth for you, and your tongue was everywhere—assertive, demanding, familiar in a way that terrified me. I pushed you back toward the mahogany desk, my hands fumbling with the buttons of your shirt. I wanted to see you. I wanted to feel your skin. You let out a low, guttural sound and lifted me up, sitting me on the edge of the desk. The wood was cold against my thighs, a sharp contrast to the heat of your hands as they slid up my legs. You didn't wait. You bunched the silk of my dress up around my hips, your eyes never leaving mine. You looked at me with a ferocious intensity, like you were trying to memorize the exact shade of my pupils in this light. “Do you have any idea?” you whispered, your voice ragged. “How many times I’ve seen you across a room and wanted to do this?” “Show me,” I said. You dropped to your knees. There was no preamble. You pushed my knees apart, and then your face was there, buried in me. I let out a sound I didn't recognize—a sharp, high-pitched gasp that echoed in the quiet suite. The feeling of your tongue was electric. You weren't tentative; you knew exactly what you were doing. You used your thumbs to pull me open, and you went to work with a focus that was almost clinical in its precision, but devastating in its effect. I arched my back, my fingers clawing at the edge of the desk. I watched the top of your head, the way your dark hair caught the dim light. The sensation was building, a tight coil in my gut that was spinning faster and faster. Every flick of your tongue, every suctioning press of your lips, felt like it was stripping away layers of the woman I’d spent years pretending to be. “Elias, please,” I choked out. You didn't stop. You moved faster, your hands gripping my thighs so hard I knew I’d have bruises in the shape of your fingers by morning. I didn't care. I wanted the bruises. I wanted the proof. When I came, it was violent. My whole body shuddered, and I had to bite my lip to keep from screaming. You stayed there until the last of the tremors faded, your breath hot and wet against my skin. Then you stood up, your face flushed, your eyes dark with a hunger that made my knees weak. You stripped off your shirt, tossing it somewhere into the shadows. Your chest was lean and corded with muscle, and there was a line of dark hair that disappeared into the waistband of your trousers. I reached for your belt, my hands shaking. I couldn't get the buckle undone, and I let out a frustrated sob. “Hey,” you said, taking my hands. “Look at me.” I looked. “This isn't a race. We have the whole night. Marc isn't calling until tomorrow.” The mention of his name should have been a cold shower. It should have snapped the spell. But in that moment, it just felt like a detail in a script I’d already tossed in the trash. You finished undressing, and then you were back, pulling me off the desk. You walked me backward toward the bed, stripping the dress off over my head in one fluid motion. We were both naked now, the blue light from the window casting long, dramatic shadows across our bodies. You pushed me down onto the high-thread-count sheets. They were cold for a split second before your weight was on top of me. You were heavy, and I loved it. I wanted to feel the full mass of you, to feel the difference between your body and the one I’d grown used to. Marc was soft; you were all angles and tension. You entered me with a slow, deliberate thrust that felt like it was carving a path through my soul. I wrapped my legs around your waist, pulling you deeper, wanting to erase the space between us. You started to move, a slow, rhythmic grind that was agonizingly perfect. “Tell me,” you groaned, your face buried in the crook of my neck. “Tell me you wanted this.” “I wanted this,” I said, and for the first time in years, I wasn't lying. “I’ve wanted this since the wedding. Since you looked at me during the toast.” “I hated you that day,” you said, pulling back to look at me. You were thrusting harder now, the sound of our skin meeting filling the room. *Slap, slap, slap.* It was a cinematic sound, rhythmic and raw. “I hated you for choosing him. For being so safe.” “I’m not safe,” I gasped, my head tossing back against the pillows. “I’m not safe now.” “No,” you said, your grip on my hips tightening as you increased the pace. “You’re definitely not.” You started to move faster, your breaths coming in short, sharp bursts. I could feel the friction building, the delicious ache of you filling me, stretching me. I reached down, my fingers finding the place where we met, adding to the sensation. Your eyes went wide, and you let out a low growl, your movements becoming more frantic, more desperate. We were a mess of limbs and sweat and tangled sheets. I felt like I was dissolving, like the boundaries of my body were blurring. I watched the way your shoulder muscles bunched and released, the way the light caught the sweat on your brow. It was a beautiful shot—the kind of thing a director would spend hours trying to light, but here it was, real and messy and perfect. I felt the climax coming again, a tidal wave this time. I clung to you, my nails digging into your back, as you let out a long, broken sound and came deep inside me. I followed you a second later, the world narrowing down to the sensation of your pulse against mine, the smell of your skin, and the sound of the rain hitting the window. We stayed like that for a long time, tangled together in the dark. The city hummed outside, indifferent to the fact that we’d just set fire to our lives. “What happens now?” I asked eventually. My voice sounded small in the large room. You rolled onto your side, pulling the duvet over us. You traced the line of my collarbone with your index finger. “Now,” you said, “we order room service. We drink the rest of that cognac. And we pretend the sun isn't going to come up.” And we did. For a few hours, we lived in the space between the scenes. We talked about things we never could have talked about at those family dinners. You told me about the time you almost moved to Berlin, and I told you about the way I felt when I realized I’d married the 'idea' of a man rather than the man himself. We laughed, which was the most surprising part. We were two people who had committed an unforgivable sin, and yet, we were laughing. Around 4:00 AM, the rain finally stopped. The silence that followed was even heavier than the rain had been. You fell asleep, your arm thrown across my chest, your breathing steady and deep. I watched you for an hour. I watched the way your eyelashes cast shadows on your cheeks. I thought about the way your hands felt on me. And I realized that I couldn't stay. If I stayed until you woke up, I’d never leave. I’d stay in this suite, in this city, until the walls closed in on us. I’d let the fire burn everything down until there was nothing left but ash. And as much as I wanted that—as much as every cell in my body was screaming for me to stay in this bed—I knew I didn't have the courage to be the villain in everyone else's story. So I got up. I dressed in the dark, my movements quiet and precise. I found the keys to Marc’s apartment on the nightstand and put them in my purse. I sat down at this desk, and I started writing this. Elias, I love the way you see the world. I love the way you see me. But we aren't the leads in this movie. We’re the supporting characters who have a brief, scandalous affair in the second act before the plot moves back to the people who actually matter. I’m going to leave this on the desk. No, I’m not. I’m going to take it with me. If I leave it, you’ll find me. And if you find me, I’m lost. Thank you for the rain. Thank you for the bruises. Thank you for making me feel like I was alive, even if it was just for a few hours in a hotel suite we couldn't afford to stay in. Goodbye, Elias. *** I fold the letter now, the paper yellowed at the edges. The Malibu sun is bright—too bright, really. It shows every line, every crack, every mistake. I never saw him again. Not really. There were more family dinners, of course. More awkward conversations about real estate and politics. We became experts at the 'long-shot' look—the one where you’re looking at someone from across a room, but you’re actually looking at a memory. Marc and I divorced two years later. It wasn't because of Elias. Not directly. It was just that once you’ve seen the world in high-contrast, you can’t go back to the flat, grey light of a life that doesn't fit you. I heard Elias moved to London. He finally finished that script. It was a hit—a dark, gritty noir about a man who falls in love with the one person he can’t have. I saw it in a theater in Santa Monica. I sat in the back row, and when the female lead walked into the rain at the end, I felt the phantom weight of a charcoal sweater against my skin. I think about that afternoon every time it rains. I think about the desk, and the window, and the way he looked at me like I was the only thing in the frame. Some stories don't need a sequel. Some stories are better left as a single, perfect, ruined scene. I stand up and walk to the edge of the deck. The wind is picking up, smelling of salt and kelp. I look at the letter one last time. I could find him. I know where he is. A quick search, a phone call, a flight to Heathrow. It would be so easy to rewrite the ending. But I don't. I tear the paper into small, jagged pieces. I let them fall from my fingers, watching as the wind catches them and carries them out over the water. They look like confetti. Or maybe like snow. Either way, the scene is over. Fade to black.

You might also enjoy

The Vintage of Unspoken Desires

The Alchemist's Shadow in the Glass

The Architecture of Complete Surrender